In a pivotal decision, the Illinois Supreme Court has overturned the 2021 conviction of Jussie Smollett, the former Empire actor accused of staging a 2019 hate crime and lying to police. 

This landmark ruling resolves years of legal battles surrounding the controversial case, focusing on due process and the state’s responsibility to honor legal agreements.

Smollett was initially charged in 2019 after Cook County State's Attorney Kim Foxx agreed to drop charges in exchange for a $10,000 payment and community service. However, a special prosecutor later reopened the case, leading to a trial and conviction. 

The Illinois Supreme Court ruled that reopening the case violated Smollett’s Fifth Amendment rights, citing established legal precedent that reneging on agreements with defendants is “fundamentally unfair.”

The court emphasized that while the case attracted significant public scrutiny, ensuring the integrity of legal agreements is paramount. It stated:

“What would be more unjust... would be a holding from this court that the State was not bound to honor agreements upon which people have detrimentally relied.”

The ruling drew parallels to the 2021 reversal of Bill Cosby’s conviction by Pennsylvania's highest court. In that case, the court invalidated Cosby’s conviction due to a prior agreement with prosecutors not to pursue criminal charges. 

The Illinois court similarly found that the state’s actions against Smollett were arbitrary and violated his due process rights.

A Timeline of the Controversy

• January 2019: Smollett reported being attacked near his Chicago apartment by men who allegedly shouted racist and homophobic slurs, poured chemicals on him, and placed a rope around his neck.
  Advertisement
• March 2019: Police accused Smollett of orchestrating the attack, citing evidence from brothers Abimbola and Olabinjo Osundairo, who claimed Smollett paid them $3,500 to stage the incident.
• March 2019: The Cook County State's Attorney's Office dropped charges in a deal requiring Smollett to forfeit his bond and complete community service.
• June 2019: A special prosecutor reopened the case, leading to Smollett's indictment on six felony counts of disorderly conduct in February 2020.
• December 2021: A jury convicted Smollett on five counts, resulting in a sentence of 150 days in jail, $120,000 restitution, and 30 months of probation.

Smollett’s attorney, Nenye Uche, praised the ruling, calling it a victory for the rule of law:

“This was not a prosecution based on facts but a vindictive persecution. We are pleased that justice has prevailed.”

The case has divided public opinion, with critics arguing that Smollett’s initial actions damaged the credibility of real victims of hate crimes. Others support the court’s stance that the state must uphold its legal agreements to maintain trust in the justice system.

The Illinois Supreme Court’s decision nullifies Smollett’s previous convictions and sends the case back to a lower court for formal dismissal. 

This marks the likely end of a legal saga that has captivated the nation, leaving questions about the implications for high-profile legal cases and the responsibilities of prosecutors in honoring agreements.